Bug Verify


Yu, Ke <ke.yu@...>
 

Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that is fixed but not verified. According to the process, it is reporter's responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask the reporter's help on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality assurance. Thanks a lot for your effort.

ID Sev Pri Architecture Reporter Status Resolution Summary
530 nor Med All anna.dushistova@gmail.com RESO NOTA Preferences:clicking "restore defaults", then "OK" leads to the error dialog
534 nor Med All anna.dushistova@gmail.com RESO FIXE Target dropdown is not updated automatically and contains empty string as default
537 nor Med All anna.dushistova@gmail.com RESO NOTA cannot build the "Hello World" Yocto SDK project
527 nor Med x86_ barrett.heyneman@gmail.com RESO WONT Partial application of user contributed patch
373 nor Med All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE kernel: allow BSP boostrapping
421 nor Med All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE beagleboard: create a beagle board BSP
422 nor Med All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE routerstation: create initial routerstation pro BSP
423 nor Med All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE fsl-mpc8315e-rdb: create initial BSP
372 nor Und All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE kernel: out of sync trees can cause opaque error messages when forcing branches
399 nor Und All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE defconfig is not automatically included
500 nor Und All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE mpc8315e-rdb: PACKAGE_EXTRA_ARCHS is mismatched
501 nor Und All bruce.ashfield@windriver.com RESO FIXE gst-ffmpeg: powerpc build errors
538 nor Med mips changhui.liu@windriver.com RESO FIXE Could not display mouse cursor on qemumips
155 maj Med All david.c.stewart@intel.com RESO FIXE Need a 5-minute newbie user guide
96 maj Hig All david.c.stewart@intel.com RESO FIXE References to purple on support page and Poky Handbook
236 nor Low x86 dongxiao.xu@intel.com RESO WONT linux-libc-headers do_install task failed.
313 nor Med All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE PDF orphans image captions
315 nor Med All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Additional package requirements
316 nor Med All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE QuickStart claims 20 GB of space (I needed 49)
318 nor Med All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE QuickStart: /dev/fb0 write permission required
532 nor Med All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE INC_PR is not documented
317 nor Med All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Poky Tarball name doesn't match top level directory
582 nor Und All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Cleanup recipes using dead variables
361 nor Low All dvhart@linux.intel.com RESO DUPL 'bitbake -c listtasks' doesn't output to stdout
455 nor Med All edwin.zhai@intel.com RESO FIXE Contacts doesn't work well on RC1 image
458 nor Med x86_ edwin.zhai@intel.com RESO FIXE No shutdown icon on the desktop for qemux86-64 image
525 nor Und All elizabeth.flanagan@intel.com RESO FIXE quilt: configure fails when using patch @ 2.6.1.81-5b68
544 nor Und All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO FIXE package-index broken
85 nor Med All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO OBSO Kernel modules not built with pstage packages
533 nor Und All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO FIXE SSTATE_MIRRORS causes meta tree pollution
351 nor Med All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO FIXE Can't build e2fsprogs-native
548 nor Med All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO FIXE bitbake listtasks broken
88 nor Hig All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO DUPL Which host/cross GDB to use?
554 nor Med All gary@mlbassoc.com RESO FIXE Can't build meta-toolchain-sdk as libart-lgpl_2.3.21.bb fails on unpack
269 nor Med All jeff.polk@windriver.com RESO FIXE sstate manifests need to be ordered
162 maj Hig All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO FIXE finalize poky build tree sysroot directory structure
382 nor Med All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO FIXE oprofile-viewer connect to oprofile-server takes forever for PPC
493 nor Med All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO FIXE OProfileServer spawning of oprofilectl failure will show through OProfile-viewer
505 nor Med All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO WONT exit lttv-gui report error
190 enh Med All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO FIXE Setup update capability for Yocto Linux Eclipse Plug-in
518 nor Und All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO NOTA poky tree mode meta-ide-support lacking gtk+-2.0 support
129 maj Hig All jessica.zhang@intel.com RESO FIXE Add TCF Remote agent to SDK images
137 nor Med x86 jiajun.xu@intel.com RESO DUPL Icons broken with qemux86 poky-image-sato image
559 nor Und All josh@linux.intel.com RESO WONT Additional comments field should follow existing comments
82 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Dismissing the dialog asking for sudo password breaks interaction
114 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO WORK Don't touch network interfaces while booting
116 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE NFS rootfs
454 nor Und All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Sanity test for 32bit libraries is incorrect on Ubuntu/Debian 64bit systems
68 nor Hig All josh@linux.intel.com RESO OBSO Use of uppercase characters in matchbox-keyboard doesn't work and results in matchbox-keyboard crashing in N800 image
108 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Possible contention when multiple package outputs enable
254 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO WONT Should really use GIO
528 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE gcc-cross-canadian package names should include the target architecture
113 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE udev local rules references parent sysfs directory
121 nor Med All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE undefined users during boot
83 nor Hig All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Remove experimental status from gdb integration
84 nor Hig All josh@linux.intel.com RESO WORK Deploy action cannot be cancelled
109 nor Hig All josh@linux.intel.com RESO FIXE Rootfs dependency failure does not cause error
122 nor Hig All josh@linux.intel.com RESO DUPL oprofile not being included in SDK images
496 nor Med All ke.yu@intel.com RESO INVA [QT] I18N issue: qtdemo webbrowser can not display Chinese page correctly
475 nor Med x86 kunwei.tian@intel.com RESO NOTA [qemux86]fail to reboot
367 nor Med x86_ kunwei.tian@intel.com RESO NOTA [qemu-x86-64-sato]connection refused when run ssh command
514 nor Med All lei.mei@intel.com RESO FIXE some packages were removed but also exist in distro_tracking_fields.inc
81 maj Med All levant.tinaz@gmail.com RESO FIXE SRC_URI with http or ftp path having "/download" at end fails to retrieve source
425 nor Med All lianhao.lu@intel.com RESO FIXE libust is missing in meta-toolchain & meta-toolchain-sdk
556 nor Med ppc lianhao.lu@intel.com RESO DUPL do_unpack failed for libart-lgpl_2.3.21.bb for MACHINE qemuppc
133 nor Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE tools (oprofile viewer/client) does not match with tools (oprofile) server
344 maj Hig All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE qemu command is often locked recently because tap0 still exists after successfully shutdown
230 nor Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE runqemu scripts break when more than one tun/tap device is created
232 nor Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE Give better error prompt when user don't use root privilege to run poky-qemu-ifup
460 enh Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO OBSO Include qemu images into sdk tar ball
546 nor Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO DUPL libreadlines clash when installing gdb cross ipk
345 maj Hig All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE rsync is missing in ppc qemu
419 maj Hig All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE Meet internal error when building c++ project sudoku in arm-qemu target
334 nor Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE qemu-arm fails whilst building locales (Ubuntu 10.04 )
341 nor Med All liping.ke@intel.com RESO OBSO Two gtk libs are not found (arm)
343 maj Hig All liping.ke@intel.com RESO FIXE unfs-qemu ppc fails to boot
39 nor Hig All manuel.teira@telefonica.net RESO FIXE oh-puzzles owl menu doesn't show merged menus
70 nor med All manuel.teira@telefonica.net RESO FIXE epdfview recipe for Poky
360 maj Hig All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE When switching to the package_deb format, the system errors early
337 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE SUMMARY field is not automatically populated by the DESCRIPTION field
383 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE Log files are generated in the build.py exec_func
331 enh Low All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE Ensure python output from tasks is always saved to log files
200 maj Und All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE module-init-tools-cross version 3.12 segfaults in depmod.
240 maj Und All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE libproxy fails to build on x86_64 host
482 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE syslog startup script is broken
483 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE NFS server initscript does not work
484 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO NOTA ps / dbus / hal uid problem
209 maj Hig All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE prelink-native failures to build, due to missing libiberty from binutils
204 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO WORK gdb has apparently host-contamination
245 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE binutils missing the point host directories patch
385 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE python has host system contamination
404 cri Hig x86 mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE RPM segfaults on target
374 maj Hig All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE binutils and gcc do not have the poison patch enabled
379 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE siteconfig can fail if the directory already exists
381 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE augeas package fails to build if readline is not present
375 enh Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE It can be difficult to find the log files
376 enh Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE Update the insane bbclass to search for bad include and library paths
356 nor Low All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE upstream rpm location is changing
281 enh Low All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE Cleanup userspace packages description/summary
403 nor Und All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE the perform_packagecopy function is mangling file permissions
386 nor Med All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE qemugl has host system contamination issues
219 nor Low All mark.hatle@windriver.com RESO FIXE dpkg does not build properly
34 nor Low x86 matt.hoosier@gmail.com RESO WORK String collation failing
292 nor Und All nitin.a.kamble@intel.com RESO DUPL qemu-ppc is failing to execute properly
226 nor Med All nitin.a.kamble@intel.com RESO FIXE qemu binaries break after this commit : 940c2b470af70b40fc6506823cd9c43e9b621075
214 nor Und arm nitin.a.kamble@intel.com RESO FIXE oprofile recipe is failing to build on arm
218 nor Hig All nitin.a.kamble@intel.com RESO FIXE qemu-native does not generate qemu-i386 binary
305 nor Med All nitin.a.kamble@intel.com RESO FIXE qemu-native does not provide qemu-mipsel binary
53 nor Hig All pmiscml@gmail.com RESO FIXE psplash: Do correct math when centering logo
275 nor Low All pokybugbot@zenlinux.com RESO NOTA Bug Process Test Bug One
487 maj Hig All qing.he@intel.com RESO FIXE fg/bg of bash not available
350 enh Med All Richard.Purdie@intel.com RESO FIXE Clean up poky-doc-tools
400 nor Und All Richard.Purdie@intel.com RESO FIXE qt4-tools-native compile failure
285 enh Low All Richard.Purdie@intel.com RESO FIXE Improve overlay appending to FILESPATH syntax
217 nor Und ppc Richard.Purdie@intel.com RESO FIXE prelink is failing at do_rootfs time for the qemuppc machine
123 nor Med All Richard.Purdie@intel.com RESO FIXE Wrong qemu binary is used if qemu-native isn't built
221 enh Und All Richard.Purdie@intel.com RESO FIXE opkg should use /var/lib/opkg, not /usr/lib/opkg
389 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE Use a more common lockfile utility for poky's qemu scripts
391 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE Create a script to generate a "bank" of tap devices for Poky QEMU sessions to use
392 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE Add psuedo-native, qemu-helper-native, and unfs-server-native to qemu-native DEPENDS
393 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE Allow running of multiple QEMU nfs instances
415 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE poky-qemu does not accept a ROOTFS argument of poky-image-xyz
535 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE poky-qemu does not detect MACHINE correctly from yocto 0.9 release images
536 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE SDK install of poky-qemu will not run with yocto 0.9 release images unless filesystem type is explicitly given
568 nor Med All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE poky-qemu fails under common usage scenario
294 nor Low All scott.a.garman@intel.com RESO FIXE runqemu script can fail to shut down tap devices
104 cri Hig All susie.li@intel.com RESO FIXE Yocto Linux 0.9 feature list need be updated
396 nor Hig All tom.zanussi@intel.com RESO FIXE Make linux-wrs the default kernel for emenlow
311 nor Med x86 tom.zanussi@intel.com RESO FIXE fixes for perf
450 nor Med All tom.zanussi@intel.com RESO FIXE [atom-pc] Undefined video mode message on boot
451 nor Med All tom.zanussi@intel.com RESO NOTA poky-image-sdk-live-emenlow 'install' fails with nonsensical partition size
531 nor Med All tom_rini@mentor.com RESO FIXE 'rm_work' is run much later than expected, when INHERIT'ed
575 nor Med arm wd@denx.de RESO DUPL mtd-utils_1.4.1 fails to build
473 nor Med All xianchao.zhang@windriver.com RESO DUPL shared libraries libtasn1.so loading error
359 nor Low x86 xianchao.zhang@windriver.com RESO INVA Some icons broken in qemux86 images
552 nor Med othe xianchao.zhang@windriver.com RESO FIXE autobuild missing the non-x86 realboard images
215 nor Low All yosoy@danieldiaz.org RESO FIXE netbase 4.41 not available in Debian mirrors

Regards
Ke


Joshua Lock <josh@...>
 

On Mon, 2010-12-13 at 17:20 +0800, Yu, Ke wrote:
Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that is fixed but not verified. According to the process, it is reporter's responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask the reporter's help on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality assurance. Thanks a lot for your effort.
I've just gone through and verified the bugs I've filed. I think we
could make this process easier to remember if we had a shared saved
search "bugs I need to verify"?

Cheers,
Joshua
--
Joshua Lock
Intel Open Source Technology Centre


Tian, Kevin <kevin.tian@...>
 

From: Joshua Lock
Sent: Monday, December 13, 2010 7:49 PM

On Mon, 2010-12-13 at 17:20 +0800, Yu, Ke wrote:
Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that is fixed but not verified.
According to the process, it is reporter's responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask the
reporter's help on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality assurance. Thanks
a lot for your effort.

I've just gone through and verified the bugs I've filed. I think we
could make this process easier to remember if we had a shared saved
search "bugs I need to verify"?
You should be able to save that search under your account directly... :-)

Thanks
Kevin


Joshua Lock <josh@...>
 

On Mon, 2010-12-13 at 19:56 +0800, Tian, Kevin wrote:
From: Joshua Lock
Sent: Monday, December 13, 2010 7:49 PM

On Mon, 2010-12-13 at 17:20 +0800, Yu, Ke wrote:
Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that is fixed but not verified.
According to the process, it is reporter's responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask the
reporter's help on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality assurance. Thanks
a lot for your effort.

I've just gone through and verified the bugs I've filed. I think we
could make this process easier to remember if we had a shared saved
search "bugs I need to verify"?
You should be able to save that search under your account directly... :-)
Of course, but I can only create a saved search for myself (and I now
have that).

However, I was assuming the bugzilla admin could create a search which
would show the logged in user all of their bugs which need verifying.

Just trying to think of ways to make this process more obvious for the
team.

Cheers,
Joshua
--
Joshua Lock
Intel Open Source Technology Centre


Tian, Kevin <kevin.tian@...>
 

From: Joshua Lock [mailto:josh@linux.intel.com]
Sent: Monday, December 13, 2010 8:07 PM

On Mon, 2010-12-13 at 19:56 +0800, Tian, Kevin wrote:
From: Joshua Lock
Sent: Monday, December 13, 2010 7:49 PM

On Mon, 2010-12-13 at 17:20 +0800, Yu, Ke wrote:
Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that is fixed but not verified.
According to the process, it is reporter's responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask
the
reporter's help on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality assurance.
Thanks
a lot for your effort.

I've just gone through and verified the bugs I've filed. I think we
could make this process easier to remember if we had a shared saved
search "bugs I need to verify"?
You should be able to save that search under your account directly... :-)
Of course, but I can only create a saved search for myself (and I now
have that).

However, I was assuming the bugzilla admin could create a search which
would show the logged in user all of their bugs which need verifying.

Just trying to think of ways to make this process more obvious for the
team.
Got it. I'm not an export on Bugzilla. Perhaps Kangkang can have some comment whether
this is feasible. It looks a good thing though. :-)

Thanks
Kevin


Scott Garman <scott.a.garman@...>
 

On 12/13/2010 01:20 AM, Yu, Ke wrote:
Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that
is fixed but not verified. According to the process, it is reporter's
responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask the reporter's help
on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality
assurance. Thanks a lot for your effort.
I have now verified all my bugs.

However, the process doesn't seem right to me. As the person who fixed the bug, presumably I performed verification that my fix actually works, which is why I marked the bug as fixed to begin with.

At every other company I've been with, bug verification is performed by the QA team - and I think the purpose of it is to ensure someone other than the developer who fixed the bug can independently verify the bug is indeed resolved. A second pair of eyes can spot new problems more easily.

JMO,

Scott

--
Scott Garman
Embedded Linux Distro Engineer - Yocto Project


Bruce Ashfield <bruce.ashfield@...>
 

On 10-12-13 11:47 AM, Scott Garman wrote:
On 12/13/2010 01:20 AM, Yu, Ke wrote:
Hi,

I hate to raise this question, but there is still bunch of bugs that
is fixed but not verified. According to the process, it is reporter's
responsibility to verify the bug, so could I ask the reporter's help
on this? Process is sometime tedious but helpful to quality
assurance. Thanks a lot for your effort.
I have now verified all my bugs.

However, the process doesn't seem right to me. As the person who fixed
the bug, presumably I performed verification that my fix actually works,
which is why I marked the bug as fixed to begin with.

At every other company I've been with, bug verification is performed by
the QA team - and I think the purpose of it is to ensure someone other
than the developer who fixed the bug can independently verify the bug is
indeed resolved. A second pair of eyes can spot new problems more easily.
I'd second Scott's opinion here. I wasn't marking my bugs
as verified, since as a submitter, I've never had to do
this in 10+ years in the 'biz'.

Cheers,

Bruce


JMO,

Scott